We Are Open for Indoor & Outdoor Dining
Take Out Available

Open Wednesday – Monday starting at 5:30pm
(Closed Tuesday)

Please order online or call after 2:00pm to place your take out order 631.324.3550. Credit cards only please.

Welcome to Nick & Toni’s

Opened in 1988, our flagship restaurant in East Hampton remains a charming and dependable table for a delicious and seasonally inspired meal in a community ripe with edible bounty. While the Tuscan farmhouse setting, wood-burning oven, extensive drink program, and outsider art all add to the ambiance, the energy of the dining rooms seem to take on a life of their own thanks to the vivacious diners who fill our seats night after night.

DINNER MENU

For the Table

Warm Rosemary, Thyme, Sea Salt Focaccia Whipped Honey Ricotta, Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil 20

Nick & Toni’s Zucchini Fritti Lemon 18

Castelvetrano & Alfonso Olives 10

Artisanal Cheese Selection Marcona Almonds, Dried Fruit Toast, Housemade Jam, Raw Honey, Seasonal Fruit 26
La Tur (cow, sheep, goat), Grafton Village 2 Year Cheddar (cow), Ewephoria Gouda (sheep)

Antipasti

Castelfranco & Baby Beet Salad Halsey Farms Apples, Marcona Almonds, Feta, Aged Sherry Vinaigrette 23

Romaine Salad Garlic Croutons, Grana Padano, Caesar Dressing 20

Wood Oven Roasted Bartlett Pears Stracciatella, Toasted Hazelnuts, Grilled Sourdough 26

Prince Edward Island Mussels Cotechino Sausage, Cannellini Beans, White Wine 28

Primi

Penne alla Vecchia Bettola Spicy Oven Roasted Tomato, Grana Padano 19/27

Hen of the Wood Mushroom Risotto Burgundy Black Truffle, Thyme 28/48

Rigatoni Bolognese Pork, Beef, Soppressata, Grana Padano 23/38

Secondi

Eggplant Polpettine Green Lentils, Oven Roasted Tomato, Fennel Pollen 34

Wood Fired Market Catch Balsam Farm Baby Kale, Fregola, Pistachio Gremolata 44

Cod Puttanesca Capers, Cerignola Olives, Roasted Tomatoes 46

Roasted Free Range Chicken  Yukon Gold Potatoes, Pancetta, Roasted Garlic, Rosemary Jus 36

Long Island Duck Breast* Cauliflower Puree, Caramelized Chicories, Cherry Reduction 44

Wood Grilled Prime New York Strip Steak* Peperonata, Baby Watercress 65

Contorni

Baby Spinach, Chickpeas, Lemon 14

Roasted Mushrooms 16

Crushed Yukon Gold Potatoes 12

Broccolini, Lemon-Breadcrumbs 15

**************

Pizza al Forno

Margherita Pomodoro, House-made Mozzarella, Basil 24

Patate al Forno Roasted Potato, Stracchino, Rosemary 26

Stracciatella Tomato Confit Pesto, Prosciutto, Caramelized Shallots 27

Salsiccia Pork Sausage Ragú, Bechamel, Smoked Provolone, Basil 28

Add ~ Arugula 5, Hot Honey 3, Marinated White Anchovies 5, Mushrooms 6, Pepperoni 6

**************

Dolci

Dark Chocolate Cake Chocolate Cremeux, Chocolate Ganache, Cold Brew Espresso Chip Gelato 17

Maple Crème Caramel Maple Caramelized Pecans, Milk Pail Apple Compote  16

Bombolini Toasted Meringue, Pumpkin Cremeux, Oatmeal Crumble  15

Almond Biscotti Riofavara ‘Notissimo’ Moscato di Noto 2014   14

House-made Gelato Vanilla, Chocolate, Salted Caramel 12

House-made Sorbet Pear 12

Nick & Toni’s Tartufo (for two) Caramel Truffle, Chocolate & Hazelnut Gelato, Almond Biscotti Crumbs   28

Artisanal Cheese Selection
La Tur (cow, sheep, goat), Grafton Village 2 Year Cheddar (cow), Ewephoria Gouda (sheep),
Marcona Almonds, Dried Fruit Toast, Housemade Jam, Raw Honey, Seasonal Fruit
26

Chef de Cuisine: Courtney Sypher-Barylski
Pastry Chef: Kelsey Roden

We do not allow outside dessert at Nick & Toni's.
*Consuming raw or undercooked meat, fish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness,
especially if you have certain medical conditions. Not all ingredients are listed on the menu.

Click on the menus below to download a full PDF.

Dinner Menu | Dinner & Pizza Menu | Dessert Menu | Beverage Menu | Wine List | Spotlight List

Our Location

Nick & Toni's
136 North Main Street at Cedar Street
East Hampton, New York 11937
Get Directions

Hours

Open Wednesday–Monday starting at 5:30pm
(Closed Tuesday)
INDOOR & OUTDOOR DINING
TAKEOUT AVAILABLE
Call in take out order in advance.
Credit card payment preferred.

Contact Us

Phone: 631-324-3550
nickandtonisgm@gmail.com
Online Reservations 
(no reservations via email please)

 
 

No pets are allowed on the restaurant property.

Service animals, as defined by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), that are specifically trained to aid a person with a disability are welcome. Dogs whose sole function is to provide comfort or emotional support do not qualify as service animals under the ADA and are not permitted in the restaurant.

Events

Nick & Toni's is a great place to celebrate with friends. We have two rooms that can be reserved for up to 30 guests each or reserve the entire restaurant for up to 80! If you would rather enjoy our cuisine and service in the comfort of your own home, we also offer off-site catering through our catering company, Honest Catering. Contact us today to schedule your event!